Unpacking the Injustice: Why Is the US Government Failing Rape Survivors in the Military?

The US House of Representatives is currently engaged in discussions regarding the possibility of allowing lawmakers to file a lawsuit against the government itself for the alleged surveillance of its members. This initiative raises serious questions about accountability and the rights of those in power. However, this proposed measure stands in stark contrast to the ongoing struggle faced by military veterans, particularly those who have survived the harrowing experience of sexual assault at the hands of their fellow service members. These brave individuals, who have dedicated their lives to serving and protecting their country, are often met with a system that not only overlooks their suffering but actively perpetuates injustice through victim blaming, retaliation, and emotional abuse. Tragically, they find themselves unable to seek legal recourse against the government for the profound trauma they have endured during their service, highlighting a glaring contradiction within the framework of justice and support that is supposed to be afforded to all citizens, especially those who have sacrificed so much for their nation.

One poignant example of this systemic failure is the case of veterans like Julie Jewels Smoot, who experienced the life-altering trauma of rape while stationed at Lackland Air Force Base. Julie's story is not just one of personal suffering; it reflects a broader issue that affects countless veterans who have faced similar violations. Despite the severe impact of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and the challenges of self-harm that often accompany such traumatic experiences, veterans like Julie are frequently left without adequate support systems or recognition of their plight. The mental health resources available to them are often insufficient, forcing many to bear the financial burden of their own therapy and treatment. This lack of support is exacerbated by a culture that often dismisses or minimizes the experiences of survivors, leaving them feeling isolated and unheard.

Meanwhile, lawmakers, many of whom are influenced by powerful lobbyists, seem to turn a blind eye to the stories of these survivors. The disconnect between the legislative actions being considered and the pressing needs of veterans underscores a troubling reality: those in power often prioritize their own interests over the well-being of those who have served. This post aims to delve deeper into the reasons behind the government's failure to adequately support veterans who have endured sexual assault, examining the systemic issues that contribute to this ongoing crisis. It will also explore the necessary changes that must be implemented to ensure that veterans receive the justice, support, and recognition they rightfully deserve, advocating for a shift in policy and perspective that prioritizes the voices of survivors and addresses their needs comprehensively.

The Harsh Reality for Military Sexual Assault Survivors

Sexual assault in the military is a serious problem that remains largely unaddressed. Survivors often face:

• Victim blaming and shaming from peers and superiors

• Retaliation for reporting assaults, including career damage

• Emotional abuse and isolation within their units

• Lack of access to justice or compensation for the harm suffered

  
  

Julie Jewels Smoot’s story is a heartbreaking example. While attending CS A School at Lackland Air Force Base, she was raped by a third-class petty officer. Instead of receiving support, she was blamed and shamed. The emotional toll led her to self-harm and live with severe PTSD. Yet, she must pay for her therapy out of pocket.

This treatment contradicts the military’s stated core values of Honor, Courage, and Commitment. Survivors expect the government to protect and care for them, not abandon them.

The Government’s Double Standard on Lawsuits

Congress recently passed a significant bill that allows citizens to sue the government if they find themselves victims of unlawful surveillance or spying. This legislative move indicates a growing recognition within the government of the necessity to protect individual rights, particularly in the context of privacy and civil liberties. It reflects a response to public outcry regarding government overreach and the need for accountability in the realm of surveillance practices. However, this acknowledgment of individual rights appears to be inconsistent when considering the plight of veterans who have suffered horrific experiences of rape and sexual assault while serving their country. In stark contrast to the protections granted to citizens regarding privacy, the government continues to deny these veterans the right to seek legal recourse for the trauma they endured during their service.

This glaring double standard is not only unfair but also profoundly unjust. Survivors of military sexual assault face a multitude of lifelong consequences that can severely impact their mental and physical health. Many of these individuals struggle with debilitating conditions such as post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), severe depression, anxiety, and a range of physical injuries that may never fully heal. The emotional scars of such traumatic experiences can lead to a cycle of suffering that extends far beyond their time in service, affecting their relationships, careers, and overall quality of life. By denying them the opportunity to pursue legal action against the entities responsible for their suffering, the government not only adds insult to injury but also perpetuates a damaging culture of silence and neglect surrounding these issues.

Moreover, this lack of accountability sends a troubling message to both current service members and veterans alike: that their experiences and suffering are not valued or taken seriously. It fosters an environment where victims may feel discouraged from coming forward, fearing that their voices will go unheard and their pain will remain unacknowledged. The consequences of this systemic neglect can be devastating, leading to feelings of isolation and hopelessness among survivors who already feel betrayed by the very institutions that should protect them. Addressing this disparity in how the government treats cases of surveillance versus cases of military sexual assault is crucial for fostering a just and equitable society, where all individuals, regardless of their circumstances, are afforded the dignity and respect they deserve.

The Role of Lawmakers and Lobbyists

Many members of Congress and the Senate receive millions of dollars from lobbyists, a practice that raises significant ethical concerns regarding the influence of money in politics. Despite this financial backing, which could ostensibly enable them to take meaningful action on pressing issues, these lawmakers frequently fail to engage with survivors of military sexual assault or to educate themselves adequately on the complexities surrounding this grave issue. They do not take the time to watch impactful documentaries such as The Invisible War or Justice Denied, which highlight the harrowing experiences of survivors and the systemic failures within the military justice system. Furthermore, they neglect to meet with survivors in person, missing the opportunity to hear firsthand accounts of trauma and resilience. Even when veterans take the initiative to send books and personal testimonies to their offices, many lawmakers choose to ignore these poignant narratives, opting instead to prioritize their relationships with lobbyists and special interest groups.

This lack of action and engagement is not merely a matter of oversight; it represents a profound betrayal of the public trust placed in elected officials. The very individuals who are supposed to advocate for the rights and wellbeing of veterans often appear to prioritize the interests of lobbyists over the urgent needs of those who have served their country. This disconnect is troubling and contributes to the ongoing neglect of sexual assault survivors within the military, perpetuating a culture of silence and impunity. As lawmakers turn a blind eye to the pleas of survivors, they inadvertently reinforce the stigma and barriers that prevent these individuals from seeking justice and support. The consequences of this negligence are far-reaching, affecting not only the survivors themselves but also the integrity of the military institution and the broader societal commitment to protecting those who have bravely served in defense of their nation.

Moreover, the failure to address these issues is indicative of a larger systemic problem within the political landscape. When financial contributions from lobbyists overshadow the voices of constituents, the very foundation of democracy is compromised. It raises critical questions about accountability and the responsibility of elected officials to represent the interests of all citizens, particularly the most vulnerable among them. As the gap widens between the experiences of survivors and the actions of their representatives, the need for reform becomes increasingly urgent. Lawmakers must be held accountable for their inaction and encouraged to prioritize the voices of those who have been silenced for far too long.

Military base barracks symbolizing isolation and neglect of sexual assault survivors

Why Veterans Like Julie Deserve More Than Silence

Julie Jewels Smoot’s experience is not unique. Many veterans who were raped by fellow service members face similar struggles:

• Paying for therapy themselves despite government responsibility

• Living with untreated PTSD and emotional scars

• Being denied recognition for their sacrifice, such as the Purple Heart or Silver Star

• Watching media like NCIS defend or excuse perpetrators, contradicting military values

  
  

Rape in the military is a betrayal of trust and safety. Survivors deserve not only justice but also recognition and support. Awarding medals like the Purple Heart would acknowledge the trauma as a service-related injury, validating their suffering.

The Financial and Moral Responsibility of the US Government

The US government spends billions overseas, engaging in various international initiatives and military operations, while simultaneously providing millions in aid to undocumented immigrants who seek refuge or a better life within its borders. However, despite these significant expenditures, it is disheartening to note that the government refuses to provide adequate compensation to veterans who have endured the traumatic experience of being raped while serving their country. These brave individuals, who have already faced numerous dangers in the line of duty, find themselves grappling with the aftermath of such horrific violations, often without the support or resources they desperately need. Survivors of military sexual trauma deserve a payment of at least $5 million, a figure that would help cover essential costs such as therapy, lost wages, and the extensive emotional damage that can result from such violations.

This demand for compensation is not merely an act of charity; rather, it represents a fundamental moral and financial obligation that society has towards its veterans. These individuals have risked their lives and well-being to protect the freedoms and values that the nation holds dear. When they are betrayed by fellow service members and the very system that is supposed to safeguard them, it is the responsibility of the government to step up and take action. Providing adequate compensation is a critical step in acknowledging the pain and suffering these veterans have endured. It signifies a recognition of their sacrifices and an understanding of the long-term consequences that such traumatic experiences can inflict on their lives.

Moreover, the failure to address these issues not only perpetuates a cycle of trauma and neglect for the survivors but also sends a troubling message about the value placed on the lives and experiences of those who have served. It highlights a disparity in how resources are allocated and raises questions about the priorities of the government when it comes to supporting its veterans. By investing in the healing and recovery of these individuals, the government would not only fulfill its ethical duty but also contribute to a more just and equitable society. It is imperative that the voices of survivors are heard and that their needs are met with the seriousness and urgency they deserve.

What Needs to Change

To address this injustice, the government must:

• Allow veterans who were raped to sue the government for damages

• Provide full coverage for therapy and medical care related to assault trauma

• Recognize sexual assault survivors with appropriate military honors

• Hold lawmakers accountable for ignoring survivor voices

• Increase transparency and reform military justice processes

  
  

These steps would begin to repair the harm done and show survivors they are valued and supported.

Military sexual assault survivors like Julie Jewels Smoot have endured unimaginable pain and neglect. The US government’s failure to provide justice and care is a stain on its commitment to those who serve. It is time for lawmakers to listen, act, and honor the sacrifices of these veterans with the respect and support they deserve. The path forward requires courage and commitment from all who hold power.

If you or someone you know is a survivor of military sexual assault, resources are available through organizations such as the Department of Veterans Affairs and nonprofit support groups. No one should face this battle alone.